Showing posts with label Segregation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Segregation. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 April 2015

Neophytes







First drafted 24.4.15 

There are plenty of places where the milongas feel intimidating to new people, there's no 'milonga-lite' at all but that's a different problem.  Notoriously Unfriendly, asked why milongas can seem to be scary, unfriendly places and proposed that it was a behavioural attitude stemming partly from temperament and partly from the way most people in the UK learn to dance at the moment, rather than a fact per se about tango dancing. 

The extension to that idea is that if you entrench that segregation of new and experienced dancers, in classes or dances, if experienced dancers do not dance with new people, which, in its most pernicious form means separate milongas for new and experienced dancers, then the route to a marvellous tanda with be a slow, tortuous and probably expensive one. You will be persuaded, you will persuade yourself, that to become good enough to attend milongas, to be good enough to dance with the “best” dancers you must attend lots of classes. 

But in fact the surest, fastest, not to mention cheapest route to that marvellous tanda is for experienced dancers to dance with new dancers. New dancers will encounter far fewer diversions - of “moves”, “steps”, “technique” and “expanding your repertoire” that way. There shouldn’t be goats. There shouldn’t be sheep. There should be people, warm and unafraid to interact with each other. Experienced people do dance with new people - all the time. There is pleasure and benefit both ways. The opposite is a myth and if that isn’t the case where you are then why is it like that and should it be and could it be otherwise? 

Thursday, 19 March 2015

Milongas - segregation or inclusion?



I wrote this piece as context against my notes about traditional tango music and dancing in Berlin because opinion is only useful if you know where it is coming from. 

I like milongas which have the right physical conditions for dancing, which play good traditional music in cortinas and where people, especially those who are not good friends, when they are not chatting will observe the non-verbal behaviours for dancing found in traditional milongas that are to do with tact and courtesy, invitation and acceptance.

There is a new milonga I like at the university in St Andrews, Scotland, more of a practica, even though it is not at all traditional.  It is attended almost entirely by young and new dancers.  They have picked up on the idea of invitation by look. I go sometimes even though there are no tandas and up to half the music can be alternative.  I go because I like the atmosphere.

I am twenty years outside the "very young" bracket and I came to tango dancing not quite three years ago; so if I go alone to dance as the woman in a place where I am not known I do not want to to compete with a room of young girls. Many men will dance first with who they know and after that with the young - sometimes vice versa  This is not uncommon in tango as in life and young women who dance with experienced partners can pick up the dance quickly and become good dancers.  Similarly, I do not want to go to milongas known to be frequented primarily by couples who tend to go to dance together.

Milongas like these (and others 'specialist' milongas - those with alternative music or those regularly featuring live music) arise in places with an established, often sizeable community of dancers, or one with a strong and specific dancing culture. They cater for different tastes in music, dance, etiquette.    There is much to be said for this separation since reconciliation between people who like different kinds of music for dancing is unlikely.  It is about finding a milonga that suits you.

Sometimes hosts will deliberately set up 'beginner' milongas.  I like milongas with variety - a mix of ages and experience. I like a dance with a local feel, non-specialist, a milonga for everyone who likes traditional music, where there are people who arrive alone, people in couples, new dancers, experienced dancers and visitors. Milongas where experienced dancers dance with new dancers are healthy environments, but not necessarily common. The local milonga playing good music in tandas with cortinas, and the right physical conditions for dancing is also vanishingly rare.  

By "a milonga for everyone", I mean everyone who comes to feel the music, to dance, not to put into practice their latest move from class or to try and remember, while in someone's arms with sublime music playing, the latest message about technique. "Everyone" includes brand new dancers because there is no faster, better way to learn to dance than by dancing with people who can already dance.

I was looking for a tag or label for this post - an antonym for segregation. Roget's suggested connection. I looked for a synonym for inclusion.  I hadn't expected the dictionary definitions for inclusion to align themselves so explicitly with what I think dancing tango and the milongas are about:   "admittance, involvement, embodiment, encompassment, embrace....".

Sunday, 21 December 2014

"Why we are often confused about what it means to be “social”" - a different view.

This interesting post offers a solution to the confusion that can occur in the social environment of the milonga.  The solution is not uncontroversial. It requires you to accept the values of the writer. This person is no ordinary social dancer.  She is a performer and works in the business of selling tango dance classes.  In the article, the emphasis shifts between the observations of a social dancer and the observations of a person with the priorities of a businesswoman:

We all know what a skillful dancer looks like...and in a milonga we always immediately identify the “good” ones.
Many of us differ in what we think a skilful and attractive dancer looks like. Not everyone who likes this is going to like this.  They are hardly the same dance. I don’t think they are the same. My seven year old son whose experience of tango dancing is socially, said, when he saw the first clip,  “That's not tango.  That's....that's....a kind of tango dance....with feet".  The music also suggests that the dances are quite different.

Youtube is full of them
...and there is a lot of rubbish on Youtube.

complaining to the organisers while they are working: all this is a disruptive behaviour that negatively affects the atmosphere.
Complaining to the organiser can be very useful - when for example there is a crowd huddled at the back of the room to get away from the painfully loud noise of the speakers at the front.  I’m fairly sure organisers would prefer to fix the situation than have people leave and spread the word.  I know I would. This happened earlier this year at a large venue and the volume came down to bearable as a result.

if a community wants to cultivate a higher level of dancing, advanced dancers should be free to dance with whomever they want to without being judged or otherwise pressured, so that they can inspire others to progress.
I agree with the idea that people should be free to accept or reject invitations to dance and that all dances that accepted should be through a real desire to dance and not through imposition/guilt at refusal.

As to “advanced” and a “higher level of dancing”, again not everyone sees these in the same way. If, say, you aspire to perform or even just do elaborate figures or fancy things with your feet, that’s one thing.  If you enjoy the pleasure of embrace and connection within the social dance, that’s a different thing. It also depends whether you see tango dancing as intrinsically about ambition and progress and technique exercises or whether that stems from something else.  Even within social dancing, there are experienced dancers with completely different styles, emphases and priorities so quite what "advanced" means starts to look a lot less clear cut.

As for inspiration, that takes many forms in a milonga as in life, and far from all of it is down to that problematic term “a higher level of dancing”.

Being too generous has a downside. It is often this “being just out of reach” of a certain desirable dancer that pushes us to grow.
Really?  Alternatively, there is the idea that understanding, empathy, encouragement and patience is at least a more pleasant environment in which to develop.

If you want generosity, first go and give it. The simplest way is to find a dancer you would normally reject and dance with him or her WITH A GENUINE DESIRE to be generous.
Except you wouldn’t dance with someone out of generosity. You would do that only if you were going to be patronising. You dance with people because you want to.

"Notoriously unfriendly?"

Recently, the tango scene where I most regularly dance did a survey which revealed a feeling that there could be unfriendliness in the local milongas towards beginners, new people and visitors. I know from talking to them that sometimes people do find it unfriendly and sometimes they find it one of the friendliest milongas.


Here in the UK, you often hear the accusation of snobbery, or elitism or unfriendliness levelled at some tango dancers, or certain milongas. You may be able to testify to this if you have danced away from your local scene, alone, in a place where you are unknown.  At one dance away several women whispered warnings to me, “this is a notoriously unfriendly milonga” and “It can take years here!”. I don't think the organiser intends at all for it to be an élitist place. One man described it simply as a "candy store for the guys" which implies at least a lot of choice for the guys and competition among the women. It is all perspective.

Talk to social dancers generally and you soon hear that tango dancers have a reputation for elitism and unfriendliness in the wider dance world. It was recently put to me by a tango dancer that dancing tango is essentially an egotistical activity, full of people seeking that high, and sometimes being quite ruthless about it.  Is that true? Ambitious dancers are not unknown, people keen to be seen or people anxious not to spoil their reputation by dancing with those who might show them to poor advantage. People dance with each other for all sorts of reasons, some obvious, some unguessable but it is often heard that some dancers will not dance with people who want to dance with them, or simply that they have a reputation for being very choosy. Tango dancing, like love, can be an unrequited affair.

This can be reflected in the way people sit - the experienced group, the beginners, the somewhere-in-the-middle and the consciously unaffiliated. Or you see it in milongas: that’s the milonga for the experienced dancers, that’s the one where they don’t take it as seriously, the level at that one is very accessible. I’ve even heard of towns in the UK where the milongas for beginners and experienced dancers are segregated. Why is tango dancing more stratified, socially?

If people naturally grouped themselves socially, by experience or ability, you would expect to see it in all social dances, in ceilidhs, Scottish Country Dances, swing, old time - all dances with a long social tradition and yet go along and I will surprised if you don’t often find people welcoming and helpful. Stratification is a function of classes and of ambition, status and things of that sort , but by no means is it a necessary consequence of experience. Socially, people usually sit and talk to people, they, well, like to sit and talk to. Which people choose depends to some extent on where their emphasis lies.

One thing that makes dancing tango different from other dances in which you find a class/pedagogic and a social element is that it begins with an embrace and is about moving together. Neither of these things are completely true of all other social, partner dances. Dancing tango is a close encounter.  Not everyone wants to embrace everyone else or move as one with them. 

Among tango dancers I was surprised to find, not a majority, but still, a sizeable number of experienced dancers who believe that everyone has to make their own way through “the levels”, the way they did. This is the “it will be as hard for you as it was for me” school of thought. People who believe this will hang on to this view with surprising tenacity, even if they acknowledge that today's new dancers will become tomorrows experienced dancers and may not thank them for their early lack of support. The notion is that everyone will either drop out and if they do it’s no loss, or they will join the experienced club, and adopt the same tough line. It is an idea compatible with the related thought that learning is what you do in class and practica, and that dancing is what you do in the milonga. In this mindset, that there is as much or more to learn through dancing and watching and chatting in the milonga is a foreign notion.

I met a couple from abroad visiting the UK who mentioned the poor quality of dancing in their town yet refused to dance with new dancers there, presumably preferring to dance away instead. This attitude isn’t the case for everybody, of course, but where it is true, it isn’t therefore surprising that you do find groups of experienced people, sharing the same view, who won’t dance with new people, who sit together which then taints the milongas with a reputation for unfriendliness. This is a behavioural attitude and one that is against social learning. It isn’t a fact about tango dancing.

For many others, dancing the dances you want to dance and at the same time including in that new people and visitors, where there is a mutual desire to dance, are not incompatible ideas. It is not at all the same as saying dance out of duty, dance a dance you'd actually rather not through ideas of kindness, helpfulness, being welcoming (or god forbid, “generosity”). That seems contradictory and misplaced because if you forced yourself to dance merely from these ideas, a partner might pick up on this and the whole situation could become rather strained as the truth dawned on them that the dance stemmed from charity rather than a desire to dance with them.

Dance because you want to. Good dancing is about enjoyment, shared pleasure. What it comes down to is where and how you find pleasure.

Photo credit: Jeremy Richardson, https://www.flickr.com/photos/jaded/13250584/in/photolist- via Creative Commons.