Showing posts with label Control. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Control. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 May 2024

Rabbit in the headlights




This piece might more literally have been titled "The effect of the dance class partner issue"

The problem with class is not just the whole contort-yourself-and-memorise aspect, the whole dance-is-thought rather than connection, music and movement.

Here’s why: when you have lived quite a long time or been on a scene a long time, of the many things you experience not all are honeysuckle and roses. When I was a few years new to tango I remember a teacher telling me that people you know in a community do die, long before I experienced it. Then you yourself witness people becoming ill. Some die. Many leave.

Alongside many moments of happiness and joy you also observe, or experience, people treated badly, cry, be traumatised by unkindness or indifference. A surprising number of people can act in awful ways and for those of us who are constitutionally deeply affected by our experiences, this is, trauma is the word.

At a recent class, harm was there, simpering, gushing, reeling everyone in. There was also a woman who I knew to be grossly, unforgivably tactless. Lastly, there was someone who had been a friend but had turned hectoring, eventually insisting I change all my values and preferences regarding going out, dancing, partners music. I tolerated this for far too long on the basis that they must think they were trying to be helpful. I tried explaining that I had my way and they had theirs but that I had much more experience in the world of the milongas and knew very well what I liked and particularly what I didn’t. When they began to demand I do what they said and became blatantly offensive I installed a figurative but permanent barrier between us as I do in all such cases. In the case of the harm, they just refused to accept the barrier, actually, literal barriers - many of them digital - which is what caused all the damage.

So the concern when you enter a room with history like that is largely the dancer partner issue. I had brought this up with another teacher whose class I had attended last year and been reassured and relieved by his response about choice and respecting limits. In that class, I knew almost no-one. There were no relational shipwrecks, no sharks I was aware of, the historical dangers were much less.

At this other, recent event, I knew, at least vaguely, most people. The first workshop hadn't require partners but I was interested enough in the teacher to be curious about the second, which did. I asked the organiser how that was going to work. The word “wars” somehow came up on my side by way of explanation.

I am regularly flabbergasted by how often people treat others as means to an end. With the Stalker, though I did not recognize it at the time, there were clues all along that our relationship was actually a relationships at all just a means to their own vaulting ambition. Twenty-first century kids might try to respin the exploitation of another as part of their own journey to "personal growth" but it isn't something that can every be justified.

A class partner seems to be seen by most as a mere vehicle for you both to learn something as opposed to another human being whom you value and with whom you have a meaningful interaction. We have understandably transactional relationships with people we pay or people of whom we ask the time or directions, or for information and are suitably grateful. This is not the relationship with a class partner because you need this person and you are going to bond with this person, however temporarily over something you consider valuable, like a learning experience. If you are in any doubt as to the value of it, recall that you have paid for it! But the relationship with the partner isn’t, or shouldn't be merely transactional. Likely we should be minimising those anyway, or at the very least be aware of the nature of our relationships with others.

“I’m sure you don’t have wars”, they said, lightly.

“Many!” I replied, only partly tongue in cheek. There was no point pretending, Some of us are known to be Knox-like, albeit quieter. They seemed surprised, but acted well.

“Cold wars”, I modified, then worried it sounded too nuclear.

They asked who I was happy to partner and after, pragmatically but on my part uncomfortably going through various names and darting off to speak with people, came up with one. This was generous. One doesn’t want to be such trouble. One also doesn't want to be foisted on someone unwilling either so I checked with the partner in question if she was happy with that.

In practise, after every exercise we in fact changed partner. This may not be the case for most people but for some of us it is frankly disturbing and not just because of being left with people you actively will not partner. Experience teaches you just don’t know who you are going to get. For me this really isn’t so much about how they dance, more about how they are as people. But then for me how you dance is all about how you are as a person or, if you prefer, how you are as a person is entirely expressed in your dance. It can be the great joy, that fast and wordless understanding of another being.

This is a why a practica is potentially so much better for learning - you choose to connect with someone compatible with the mutual agreement to try and learn something. The downside is most people use practicas to dance socially, there isn't enough of a culture that values mutual assistance or knows how to initiate it and you need two people who either can learn from each other or one is willing to help the other. None of this is easy to find, on top of which our culture is now such that unless it is done under the "volunteering" banner, helping someone freely has a become an almost bizarre and unnatural concept.

At the very first change of partner I got someone I can remember starting to dance some years after me. They began with a lecture on how to engage in the exercise. I felt a combination of inadequacy but more annoyance which I must have hidden because they continued unperturbed then behaved with such indifference during the actual movements that I just felt depressed.

I suppose one strategy in an environment like that is, at the beginning of each exercise, to proactively rush to find the kindest people or those you find most tolerable to partner but when you are already so overcome with doubts, the other option is to hang back with dread and misgiving, clutching the wall and see who is left. It was the tactless one so I went, unnecessarily, to the loo.

A long-standing teacher in the room, present as an attendee, seemed to have noticed. Was everything OK? I could have just decided to sit that one out instead of hiding in the loo, which recalled my early dance-class days when women would develop weak bladders as soon as a guy they did not want to partner came round. It was the frequence and awkwardness of these moments that eventually did for my attendance at class. But here I was again ten years later taking refuge in the toilet. This time I did sit out the rest of the exercise before spontaneously joining the kind teacher-attendee with their partner.

By this stage this world in miniature felt crushing. The explanations were comprehensible, The demonstration of connection or its absence, so visible in tiny changes of movement, was admirable.  The arc of the lesson and its relation to the theme was visible.  But in practice, with all this stuff to do with people going on, engaging with the content of the lesson was hard. Each change of partner was like being in a test with a blank page and next to no memory of the question. Rabbit in the headlights.

Partnering two other teachers and the main teacher I did learn interesting things, began to feel a little less under siege. I also partnered a friendly beginner, had fun and played around. But, emotionally, one of these workshops was more than enough.

Monday, 3 July 2023

Machismo (III): another view

Swastik Arora
                                                  

 - No, it's true, said a gentle English/ Scottish friend, referring to women being the cause of male machismo. 

I blinked in disbelief.

Earlier, we had seen the Mela being dismantled in Kelvingrove park in Glasgow.  He pronounced it me-la, with a pause and a faint lilt.  

- Why do you pronounce it like that?

- It's a Punjabi word.

- Are you bilingual?

A couple of weeks later it transpired he was trilingual, speaking, or at least understanding Hindi as well 

- Yes.

He has a lovely embrace. He will dance in the woman's role with me, but only once - on my recommendation and with great reluctance - did he ever dance with a man. 

- What do you mean "It's true"? And how do you know? Have you been to Latin America?

- Same culture, he said, pointing his thumb to his chest as he drove me through the city.  The mums don't want their boys  growing up not macho.

- Why not? 

- Because that would mean they were weak, soft.

- So I guess gay is out of the question then?

- Oof! 

- Is that why you don't like dancing with men, to learn to dance tango?

- Yes.

He'd grown up being taught that kind of thing was wrong. 

- And why none of the guys I've met from the eastern Mediterranean - Jordan, Syria, Palestine, Turkey -  are willing to dance in the woman's role with a guy, to learn the dance - even though that's how men in Argentina learnt traditionally?

- Probably, yes.






Sunday, 2 July 2023

Not personal

s
Edinburgh


This blog has existed for many years.  After a while, one becomes aware of which posts are going to be more popular.  For many years 'Tango, trouble and disrespect' has been the most popular post here.  The most popular entries are often the controversial ones, that point to a disagreement between people in a community.  Not always, there are other kinds too.   If I wrote for popularity I would splurge my posts across my social media, or even, with elbow-jabbing pushiness, in social media groups. I always feel sorry for writers whose social media has become relentless self promotion and wonder if they choose to do it or are made to.

Salacious curiosity underpins the entire media industry. I don't write for people trying to figure out "Whom does she mean?" .

I used to think it was useful to name some of the tracks that I heard specific DJs play, for those visiting or wanting to learn more about music. Certainly, it would be immensely useful to see a setlist or even example tracks of DJs I don't know. It would save so much travel and disappointment.

Even highlighting some of the tracks DJs play while pointedly not saying "And what a wonderful selection it was!" makes a point. It can causes aggro: not to my face and I only once, years ago, became aware if it through whispers passed around by someone, who, to general relief, is long gone. If anyone is interested enough in local music, I guess they'll ask. But the truth almost no-one travels internationally to Edinburgh to dance although some come to dance while they are here for something else. Although it's a capital, it's a small city and there aren't enough milongas.

From Being or Becoming? : The real point though is not about DJing or salsa or tango. These are just context, examples. There, although the discussion was about DJing, the point was something else. Sometimes, the point is about the DJing, but not about the person.

I don't name guys who criticise women, although they deserve it and I don't make ad hominem arguments against DJs or teachers because it's neither my place nor my point. Some entries may be stories of things that happened and therefore appear to point to real individuals, but trying to figure out who they are is irrelevant. They represent types, examples of certain behaviours or practice and that is the point.

Some people get antsy when they are referenced, even anonymously, even on a blog. Others are entirely relaxed and these I trust more. Chatting to the author of Autobiophilosophy years ago I remember he said one autobiography was enough for one lifetime, for the legal issues if nothing else.

I often think of Joseph Mitchell's classic, Up in the Old Hotel, which are pen portraits, often of named people. I think I once read that he wrote about people compassionately but upon reading it thought, Really? But the portraits are compelling.

It takes a certain sort of person to be able to detach themselves from the effect they may have on the subject of the writing. I don't know if it's courage or something else.

Friday, 30 June 2023

Just a dance?

Various (Initial version by Silje), CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons



The map is Wikipedia's current assessment of world homosexuality laws. Grey means same sex relationships are not recognised. Blue means recognised, with darker blue meaning more rights.  Brown / yellow and darker are places where same sex expression is limited or penalised.   

I had met another man from one of the countries along the far coast of the eastern Mediterranean.  Hewas young, worked in a scientific profession but categorically did not want to dance with men as a means of learning the dance.  He had, apparently some other, considerably more conservative beliefs. I had been very surprised. 

- There are a lot of people like that, said a friend from a slightly more liberal country in the same area, who dances.  

- Is homosexuality in your country illegal?

- Yes. But people turn a blind eye, as long as you keep it private.  

- So if you were gay you couldn't tell anyone?

- No! Apart from anything else, your family would disown you, quite likely kill you.

- But it's not a choice, being gay, is it?

- No, but many still think it is. Or at least it can be "controlled".

- Is your family traditional?

- Yes.  I had to go to the mosque every day.

- I had to go to chapel every day at boarding school. And church on Sundays in the holidays

We smiled at each other, laughed in shared recognition.

-  I was religious until my mid twenties.  Perhaps less from belief, more from fear.

- From fear?

- That God would smite me for example.  

I remembered that feeling.

- Religion controls people, he said, voicing my thoughts at that moment.

- Do you think there are a lot of people in that area like that, believing through fear?

- Yes, a lot of people adhere to religion through tradition, habit, fear, family pressure more than belief.

- So how is it that you have changed?

- When I started dancing tango.  I began to travel, to meet people from other cultures. 

Thursday, 29 June 2023

Machismo (II): its womens' fault

betoscopio, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Common


I asked a Venezuelan conversation exchange partner in his sixties about inclusive language.  

- Oh, no, he said, I don't use it.  

- Why not?

- It's a pain, 'pesante'.

- How so?

- Oh, all this stuff about amigos or amigas, saying both, Let's just stick with how we've always said it.

- Taking the masculine form of the pronoun, 'Todos estamos aquí' if there is say, a group?

- Of course.

- So you wouldn't say "todes".

- What?

- Todes.

- Todos, sí.

- No, todes, con "e".

- Oh, I thought there was a problem with your accent.  No, I wouldn't say that.

- But if you are a woman, not being well treated by a guy, someone patronising you for example, which is very common, the simple fact of someone, the woman or those present, using that language, making it normal, is a reminder that women have the right to be treated equally by men. The point is not to change every word, but to use certain words representing inclusive language to make a point about gender politics, about treating each other, as equals and with respect.   

- But 'lenguaje inclusivo' isn't going to change anything. It just annoys people.

I thought disconcerting some people was very probably the point.

- Do you think there's a problem with machismo particularly in say southern and eastern Europe, say and in Latin America? 

- Yes.

-What do you think is the cause of that?

- Well, it may seem strange to say, but it's the mothers.

- What?

- Yes, it's the mothers. In our culture, raising children is seen as women's work.  Men don't get involved.  

- Mothers want their boys to grow up macho? To not treat women well, to possibly hit them.

- Yes. Not to hit women necessarily, but they don't tell them not to. My mother was very strict on that point, that I must never lay a hand on a woman, but that's unusual.

- Why would women want their boys to grow up and not treat women well?

- I don't know.

He raised his shoulders and lifted his hands to express the fathomless female. 

- And what about fathers, don't they have any role or responsibility for these macho cultures? They are after all, the ones treating women badly.

- Yes, to a point.  The father starts taking an interest when the child is bigger, or an adolescent. He starts wanting to teach them to be men. So when the dad starts featuring in the child's life, it's around the age when the child is looking for a male role model and in walks a macho one. And so it is perpetuated.

And yet, this sounded startlingly familiar.  My own boys' father, who has spent more decades in this country than in his own in southern Europe, more or less disappeared for twelve years after they were born. I had a well paid career but I didn't want to hand the children over to a nursery and later, I wasn't impressed with the schools and I loved being with my children so he travelled and I raised the kids.  He always had a "grow up quickly, let's make men of you" attitude, wanted to pack them off to military school early (which hasn't happened). 

Still, I left the conversation with the Venezuelan, reeling.


Sunday, 25 June 2023

"Tango is terrible"

'Tango Macho'


After the Rosarinos had played their set of live music we chatted. She had got him playing tango music. She danced, he didn't. I asked them if they found differences in milongas in different places but they mentioned nothing in particular.

I mentioned the story from Buenos Aires that demonstrated the near zero tolerance for same sex dancing there is (or was, in 2016) in the traditional milongas there.

She was amazed that such things still happened.

I was amazed she didn't know that.

Tango is terrible, he said, with a sorrowful shake of the head. I wasn't sure if there was irony there.

What do you mean?

The lyrics, they are awful. He meant sexist.

Ultimately, sexism, machismo is about control.

And yet you travel the world, playing tango music!

Ah, but not the lyrics. There are no lyrics when we play, he grinned.

Saturday, 10 June 2023

Freedom: a cornerstone

Groyne, Monifieth, Angus


There has been a loose direction for a few months and with diversions, arising from what happened in February. It started from the themes of coercion, control, imposition, manipulation, force, stress and has nosed towards the attendant ideas of refusal and acceptance. 

The possibility of refusal or acceptance comes from "freedom from" those noxious subjects, from which comes "freedom to".
It is only once there is that freedom that one can make independent choices and from that, that there can be a possibility of good things happening.  So, I want to restate that “the absolute cornerstone of milonga culture is freedom of discreet invitation and equally discreet acceptance or refusal.” 
Freedom in the milonga and in life  can be alarming when one doesn't know what is possible, when one lacks experience, essentially, or guidance.  In life too, freedom can be overwhelming. But freedom leads to creativity, to connection, to magic in ways hard to describe, precisely because freedom is not about boxes and labels and pigeonholing. 
With notable exceptions humans are adaptable, intuitive, aware of their surroundings and good at improvisation and yet the signs put up by controlling types would lead invading aliens to believe that we are a species whose fundamental moronity is at odds with some of our great ideas, inventions and achievements.
Particularly tickling are the signs whose absurdity evokes an obvious pathetic belief, on the part of those who decided they were necessary, in their own importance. In the photo above, the groyne was blindingly obvious and not high. The danger was more in falling in the rocky descent to the beach; or from the sea itself, or from the nearby firing range, onto which, due to a surprising lack of signage, I nearly walked. But the council clearly disliked the expansiveness, the potential for freedom of the beach, the notion that it might, who knows, give people ideas. The council, then, disliking its own absence in a place largely rule-free, felt, as it so often does, that it must be at least seen to be present and controlling. These people never realise that such signs - until we come to accept them - only serve to undermine their so-called authority, mockery being the fastest and most degrading route to a fall from power.
Freedom includes freedom to explore and so much of what happens in the milonga and in life is about discovering ones preferences and avoiding what one dislikes with tact and ease and confidence. Some of the most interesting observable behaviour and some of the best stories from the milonga are around these subjects more than the dancing itself. 

Saturday, 18 March 2023

Follow my lead!

When you follow from fear!



A:  "But why do you think you "go wrong" in dance and make mistakes?"

B:  "Well, I feel I don't do what they want.  And the men tell me.  They say I'm 'not following their lead'."

What kind of interpersonal relationship is that - when someone keeps telling you you are wrong?  What kind of relationship is it that as someone embraces someone else they criticise them?    This piece was drafted back in 2016.  The following year the #metoo movement took off with the Harvey Weinstein allegations.  Since then we are perhaps more alert to abusive relationships. 

People follow best through trust, not fear and the body is more truthful than the mind.  A female body does not want to embrace a male body that keeps telling it is wrong or is going wrong.  No"body" wants to embrace any"body" that keeps being told that.  Small wonder then when you see class dancers in an open or semi-open dance "hold" instead of an embrace.  Ironically, it was an experienced teacher who once told me you be able to tell which couple will dance well from the way they first embrace.    

If the "follower" is being lectured by the "leader" there will be no true embrace and the hold will be more like a vice in which he can do unpleasant things to her.  If we don't want to be tempted by biscuits that are bad for us we don't buy them in the shop.  If we don't want to be treated badly, why accept men who lecture in dance and push us around like shopping trolleys?

 "You are not following my lead" is a cruel and tragic commonplace akin to "You are not doing what you are told". This is about control more than dance.  If people tell acquaintances and strangers on the dance floor that they are "doing it wrong" one wonders what they say to their employees, children, partners.

Friday, 17 March 2023

The Empathy Gap




In an interview the British novelist Martin Amis referred to the writer WG Sebald saying that no serious person should think about anything but the Holocaust. He said it was supposed to be ironic but that at some level he meant it, as, said, Amis, do I. It was a relief to hear this because I had considered myself odd in thinking considerably about the Holocaust, after reading some of the works on that event. Christopher Burney's book, The Dungeon Democracy, is his account of life as a British officer in Buchenwald.  He often gives little moral quarter to the prisoners themselves.  A prison guard might appear reasonably benign compared to the dog-eat-dog life of most prisoners. His point was more that people end up in various stations in life but it is their character that counts. 

Excerpt: The Dungeon Democracy



 Burney's point towards the end, as I recall, remembering now many years back, was that most of us have a capacity for extraordinary evil and that we should build our education systems with that fact in mind so that nothing like the Holocaust happens again. Amis in another interview on the controversial idea that a writer should not write about the Holocaust also says that the justification for it is so that it never happens again.


It was when I read The Dungeon Democracy and Viktor Frankl I think last year that I suddenly understood why Christopher Burney had been so anxious to publish: he knew very well that the traits of all the people who propped up that regime existed in ordinary people - the desire to control, to persecute, to rule, to oppress, to exploit, to lie and cheat and deceive, to use people as means and all for power or status or money. I looked around [a milonga] and I saw those very traits in operation, thinly masked. I realised how, in certain conditions those traits could all thrive again. So it's not just a question of preventing those conditions in society because who can predict how they come about, the danger is as much or more in the human traits themselves. [Correspondence, 2016]

Once aware of these traits and what they can become the Holocaust and related iniquities of human behaviour are never, mentally, too far away. Perhaps that is what Amis and Sebald perhaps meant. that is also why two of my key preoccupations are death and freedom. Freedom is life: freedom from so that there is freedom to. The ultimate control, the ultimate restriction, the ultimate imposition is taking away someone's life, harming their body or their mind but taking away someone's freedom is a kind of living death. 

 We endure unreasonable impositions constantly: on our time, on our freedom, women even endure them on their person and too often we put up with it for the sake of norms, so called civilized behaviour whereas we should question far more - is this reasonable, is this useful, is this fair? Death and freedom, the two great preoccupations.

Amis talks about the incomprehensibility of the Holocaust. The thing to be very alert to is when we encounter the incomprehensibility of someone's behaviour because it is a warning you have to heed. I call it the empathy gap. It is when two people find themselves on either side of a psychological chasm. It happens when you simply cannot comprehend how someone could act in that way because you cannot conceive of doing something of that nature yourself. I can't imagine being a paramedic, but I admire paramedics, so there's no empathy gap there. But when I think of the Holocaust, or Argentina's Dirty War, or the Colombian "false positives", or the common and garden capitalist exploitation of people, of the planet for profit, there is an empathy gap there. It is when you fail to understand how people can act in despicably inhumane ways. The empathy gap can be over huge, world-shaking events or the dispiriting inhumanities practised by individuals on a daily basis.

I encountered it recently and for days afterwards could not acclimatise to the idea that someone could repeatedly refuse to leave someone alone, to the point of trapping them, deliberately cornering them, as they later said to the point of extreme physical and psychological distress.  Even one of the apologies said in chilling, controlling language, they were "not going to allow another miscommunication" - as if, after everything, there was still some future, as if it was all a misunderstanding.  I felt shocked, horrified, appalled.

That shock manifested physically and I am still trying to come to terms with it.  Despite excruciating muscular pain in my neck, left shoulder collarbone, chest and arm as far as the hand it did not even occur to me for over two weeks that exercise and stretching might bring relief.  It was as though the shock had caused some psychological and mental freeze that prevented me from thinking normally.  Today exercise brings relief but whatever it is that connects all those parts is still contracted and needs daily stretching.  

It took days to mentally adjust to the fact that for some people ignoring the wishes of others, trampling repeatedly over their simplest request - to be left alone - is a right. I should have realised. I have an online advert for multi-lingual conversation exchange which, when I am busy, will say in caps lock, that I am not looking for partners at present, yet I am still bombarded with requests.  This is startling in itself but you do not expect blatant, egotistical disregard from people you know and have helped.

The key thing I learned is to spot those traits early, distance yourself and if that doesn't work don't do nothing; take some other measure because you need a plan.  You have to somehow imagine yourself on the other side of the empathy gap, to anticipate what appears to you unthinkable within your own moral scope because without that anticipation you will have no plan to deal with what can arise.  The first problem of course is realising that you are that empathy gap, before it is too late.

Monday, 13 March 2023

Bandolera / Ojos negros

Wikimedia


The lovely song, Ojos Negros, famously interpreted by Francisco Canaro's tango orchestra (1935) with the singer Roberto Maida has a long history - there is an article about this by Dmitry Pruss.

Many numbers we think of as "tango" or "milonga" have lives outside our world.  The Puerto Rican pianist Noro Morales also covered Dark Eyes in an interesting mambo version (1964) as well as Niebla del Riachuelo (1960).  What we think of Canaro's Milonga Sentimental was covered by the salsa orchestra El Gran Combo de Puerto Rico, in 1982.  Recently I heard Las Cuarenta - the best danceable tango versions are by Canaro/Maida (1941) and Lomuto / Omar (1937) - in a bolero version by Rolando Laserie.  I particularly like Lucio Demare's 1968 piano versions of many famous tangos.  They have a retrospective air which never falls into sentimentality.

During that difficult time I was listening to a lot of salsa. Bandolera, by Héctor Lavoe contains a long section of improvisation in which Ojos Negros, is referenced musically (5.27).  I asked Camilo if he could identify any other pieces in that improvisation.  He heard Historia de un amor (4.09) and Obsesión (5.16).  I would be interested if anyone can identify anything else.

The two he mentioned are apparently both boleros, love songs, which is interesting in the context of Bandolera, a song whose lyrics are in part, shockingly, about a man hitting a woman:

Pau, pau, pau
Te voy a dar
Te voy a dar una pela
[...]
Pau, pau, pau
Te vuelvo a dar
Te voy a dar pa' que aprendas
[...]
Te voy a pegar, te voy a pegar, te voy a pegar, te voy a pegar, te voy a pegar

Some of the salsa lyrics I heard at that time were apt to the situation I was trapped in:

Y por los celos, los celos, los celos
A mí el corazón me arde, me arde
Y por los celos, los celos, los celos
A mí el corazón me arde, me arde

(Gitana, Willie Colon)

There was a lie, and attempts to manipulate situations with people I dance with.

Quien dice una mentira dice dos
Y dice cien, se inventa mil
Dice un millón
El ser que ya nació para engañar
Te engaña a ti, me engaña a mí
Me engaña a mí


(Bandolera, Héctor Lavoe)

Because of these interventions, I was losing those dance partners.  I dance with new people who come to the práctica and introduce them to others, that they may discover the dance and there is pleasure in that, but people dance tango many ways and there are few enough who dance for and with the kind of musicality and connection that I enjoy.  These I value. 


So I drew a line.




(Me liberé, El Gran Combo de Puerto Rico)

Blocking communication channels was easy, and so, I thought, effective. I had seen enough and had caught the scent of danger, even if I didn’t yet know the gravity of it.

Aléjate bandolera
Aléjate bandolera
Aléjate bandolera

(Bandolera)


It was sad…

Cuando en el alma se siente un dolor
Por la traición que te brinde un amigo /
En ese momento piensa que todo es posible

(Indestructible, Ray Barretto)


…but it was also scary.

I was contorting my life to avoid harassment. I cancelled my first práctica and an invitation to a party. They said they weren't going, so I could go, tranquilamante. But my trust was shot, I didn't and I cancelled the second práctica. Then I understood they were quitting tango. I felt huge relief, published the next práctica and thought I was free.

Me liberé, me liberé
Gracias a Dios, me liberé
Me liberé, me liberé
Gracias al cielo, me liberé
Me liberé de mujeres perversas que quieren hacer mi vida de cuadritos
Me liberé de chicas sin escrúpulos,

(Me liberé, El Gran Combo de Puerto Rico)

I was wrong.  A month on, while much improved, the physical effects of that day of imposition, control and entrapment are still with me. The weeks leading up to that day are associated now with these salsa numbers and, by association, Ojos negros, particularly the chilling line, "ojos negros, que dominan".  With luck, one day some great dance will replace them.


Monday, 1 April 2019

Levels and labels

A friend wrote recently about 'levels' in dance. I have written a bit about it in other posts, especially in Notoriously Unfriendly and in "Why we are often confused about what it means to be “social”" - a different view but perhaps not explicitly.

My friend was referring to 

"the pernicious stratification and segregation by 'level' inflicted by class teachers. 'Level' being of course which level of class level you are in, as a decision of the teacher, not anything to do with your level of accomplishment in dancing. This isn't just to put the advanced material on the other side of a paywall, Scientology stye, but also do the same to past joiners. It monetises past teaching 'successes' by turning intermediate and advanced classgoers into product for which newcomers must pay.

I once heard a teacher refer to her 'class ladder'. Unintentionally apt, I think, given a key characteristic of a ladder is that once you're on it, the only way off is at the top ... or bottom."

See also: Learning naturally: most people won't. So the idea is that thinking of dancing tango, for instance, as something where people are assigned to levels: beginners, improvers, advanced -  is not helpful, is pernicious even. It doesn't just apply to learning to dance tango, it's anything. 

Putting you in a level is usually a teacher's decision. We can't assume that the teacher has your best interests at heart, especially not where money is involved. Just look at Trust me: You need me:  it is a transparent business strategy.

It is fine if you know and trust your teacher. It is the same again, with doctors. But I don't know anything about my doctors at all. Why should I trust someone I don't know? Just because of their qualifications? Yes, I trust a doctor over Joe in the street but what does that say? Not much. And in fact, I don't trust my doctors much and some I trust far less than others because I've known them on my account and my children's for well over ten years and have often found reason not to trust them. So it's not as though I started off not trusting them. I am not particularly inclined to be distrustful but I should mention that ours is a practice with the worst reviews in town.

So if we can't even trust a doctor that much on what basis should we trust a dance class teacher who can set up with no qualifications whatsoever? Doctors are at least regulated. 

But let's say our teacher seems nice. They smile. They nod. They say all the things you want to hear. They are reassuring. They have years of experience. Builders who rip you off almost routinely in the UK, not to mention second car salesmen, are the same, but leaving all that aside for convenience let's say all seems good. 

Recall, the idea of dance levels is a commercial construction. It suits the teacher to have a concept of levels because it makes money. The punter want to get to 'advanced' so you stay and stay in class, 'advancing' when the teacher says you can, until they decide they probably aren't going to make much more money out of you or eventually you twig that there are better ways to learn. The idea of other more experienced dancers as 'product' (and free advertising) is insightful.

But are you "advancing"? How do you know?  It depends on what the goal is.  What are you buying?  And if you go in buying one thing, is that thing you end up staying for?  

It is difficult where you don't know the brand. With no qualification, no regulation, this is really all about trust. So what do you go on when deciding who to trust with your exchange of money for whatever you think you want from the experience? Do you just pick the local one? The one with the best reputation? The ones who travel and perform? Plenty of people say certain teachers are great. And they can be all sorts of things: charming, funny, entertaining, hospitable, great with groups.

Unless you are going to the class for these things, they are beside the point.  The punter probably thought though that they were going to learn to dance Argentine tango.  Once they realised there was social dancing and there was Strictly style dancing they probably wanted to dance socially but they do not make the connection that they are being taught watered down Strictly type moves, or at least moves more suited to performance than social dancing.  Performance dancing is suited to 'levels' in a way that social dancing is not. 

But perhaps you don't want any of that. Maybe you just do want to work your way through the levels of dance class because that's what you want to do on a Tuesday night - and why not?   Or perhaps you started class because you wanted to learn to dance tango (whatever that meant) and ended up wanting to just stick with your group because for whatever reason you enjoy it and again, who is to censure where and how you find your pleasure? Some people like Bovril. You can love tango class on a Tuesday and no one can say anything against that. Or perhaps you do start wanting to learn to dance tango in class (because that's all you know about), and then that changes because you hear about milongas and you want to learn to be someone other people want to dance with. But recall the moral of The Frog and the Nightingale: don't mimic self-styled teachers who try to woo you.

But if you want to learn to dance tango socially, the people to ask about that are the people you see dancing socially, and who you see or better still, feel, dance well.  That is an independent judgement, by you.  Most teachers are not social dancers.  They just don't dance socially, or they don't do it much.  And of those who do, even fewer dance socially, well.  They do a different thing - they may perform and they teach dance class which I can say with confidence -  having done class and danced socially and having been to many teachers - that dancing socially and dancing in class are not the same thing at all.  Not remotely similar. One does not lead to the other.  To try and say that you can learn to dance Argentine tango socially by going through the levels of dance class is like saying you can learn to climb to the high level of a diving board only to dive into an empty pool.

I went to Newcastle the weekend before last.  On the Saturday night I went to a milonga.  I was in a good mood, the community was small. I didn't want to get into an early funk from not dancing and getting hung up on things so after I'd danced one  - good - tanda with a woman across the room, I invited a woman down the row from me even though I hadn't seen her dance and we hadn't chatted.  I rarely do this with partners, and never with guys. She was surprised I think that a woman was inviting her, but enthusiastic.  We established that yes I was inviting her to dance and I double-checked: did she dance with women? Yes, yes!, she said.  But I'm a beginner, she said clearly.  Great!  I said, meaning it.  Now it isn't actually always great dancing with beginner women but it very often is; it just depends.  But this woman was lovely to dance with.  So much so that I exclaimed in surprise:  You're not a beginner! But she had been dancing for six weeks.  It turned out she hadn't heard of tandas, cortinas, cabeceo, ronda, nothing. She didn't know about by invitation by look but she had twigged anyway when I did it. People who are attuned just pick these things up. She felt lovely to dance with. And she was sixty-five! Now if that isn't an inspiration I don't know what to tell you.

The point is, levels don't mean anything, really, not to me, anyway.  They will to some people.  You find some - usually ones who you can tell - by the way they dance - who think they are big shots.  This type thinks levels are important.  They are often teachers anyway or wannabe teachers.  They hog the floor, they get in the way of social dancers.  They dance wildly and selfishly.  They perform - usually for themselves on the social floor where it just isn't appropriate to do so.  They are very out of place. Quiet social dancers try not to end up dancing next to them. You really want them to go to the kind of milonga where people dance like them. The main thing is to suss out who thinks levels are significant and who doesn't.  And decide which of these you prefer dancing with.  

What counts is not levels, but  - I've said it many times - compatibility.  Do you feel good with the person you dance with?  Sometimes you won't feel good dancing with someone with a lot more experience.  The person with less experience is liable to think the problem lies with themselves and their inexperience but it is often just a question of incompatability.  It is like talking to someone with different values.  You click with some people and not with others.  But do we ever talk about someone being a beginner in conversation?  Not really.  Not unless they're a toddler and then we call them...a toddler because it's more meaningful! 

This lady said to me: Oh, but I've got so much work [that word again!] to do in the classes.  
- Honestly, don't think that, I said with an all-too-familiar sinking feeling, predicting the future and thinking this could be the first and last time I was to enjoy dancing with her.  
- Oh, but I do! she said.  
- Like what?  I said, not wanting to feel tired.  
- Well, my feet don't point the right way! she said, ludicrously.  But oh how many women do want their feet pointing the 'right' way. I remember wanting that, wanting to look and dance just like my teacher in all ways, never mind that she must have been a (UK) size six and close on a foot smaller than me. 
- Your feet felt fine to me!, I said laughing.  Who cares what your feet look like? I don't care.  Why would I care about your feet?  I can't even see your feet!  
- You're right, she said, laughing.  
But for some inexplicable reason, it's what the teachers say that sticks.   

Recently, while travelling, I asked a friend what an Argentine teacher who was at a milonga was like to dance with.  I had noticed he had started the evening dancing quite quietly and had gotten ever more extravagant.  She wasn't wowed, I remember.  She dances with much better social dancers by her own admission.  And yet, she pays this guy for private lessons! Tell me, please, how does that stack up?  And this is common! 

Why don't people trust their own instincts more of the time when learning to dance tango?  We go in general I think on a combination of what we think ourselves and what others tell us or what they let us know, in many things, not just dance.  We make judgements and adjustments based on this.  We do it in our social interactions all the time.  But haven't you been in a situation in life where you have learned something largely by instinct, by experience, perhaps alongside someone else who can already do it?  Perhaps it was art or cooking, or yoga, or piano, woodwork, boat-building, computers, gardening, learning languages, running, building a business, your job perhaps - the possibilities are infinite.  People do it all the time.  They start not knowing anything and get very good without ever really putting themselves into a category of beginner or intermediate or advanced. In fact we learn to talk without ever calling ourselves beginner, intermediate or advanced talkers! These categories anyway, are far too general to be of use.  I have been dancing socially for seven years but I just learnt ochos - what does that make me?  

I am learning Spanish from milongas and taxi drivers, the Duolingo stories, tango songs, parallel text  story books and videos for children and 18 rated films.  I don't know and I don't care what level I am.  What I care about is what I can do - if I can get around or read a book, or a paper, or how much of a film I can watch without referring to the subtitles. 

One of the reasons people get stuck with these beginner / intermediate / advanced (I've even heard of' maestro' (!) levels is because not just teachers but gulled students use them, often to feel better about themselves.  It is unfortunate that people sometimes say truly dreadful things in class or at the milonga.  They can put you down, run you down, make you cry.  The cruelty and tactlessness of people in social situations is endlessly variable.  I think many don't realise the effect they have.  I haven't been back to one of my local scenes for six weeks for just that reason.  One starts feeling nauseous seeing the people who have said these things and when after years the people from whom you have heard these things said, either to oneself or to others, start to add up you just stop wanting to go.  Seeing them sours the atmosphere.  But that is the risk you take going to a place where you can end up talking to random strangers or people who are nothing more than acquaintances.  Yet random people can also be kind, complimentary or interesting.  You take a chance, going there, that's all.  Sometimes you get kisses and sometimes you get knocked.  You come to notice that the crass ones start to appear fairly friendless or they ally with a similar type.  On the other hand it makes travel attractive as people tend to be on better behaviour with strangers. 

So the suggestion is just really to unstick the labels on you.  It is a good time to do it.  Labelling people is not fashionable now.  The zeigeist is swirling with chatter about the variety and uniqueness of each one of us. While that does sound trite and ripe for the sorts of social media posts about 'positive living' that frankly make me beg to see parodies (there are desperately few!), it is also true.  Who wants to be a labelled by someone else who doesn't really know you and who has all kinds of vested interests whether they are a doctor, a school teacher or a tango teacher?  Let me know your other top professions for people that label you and have power over you... 

My son came back this week saying with some sadness in his voice that he wasn't in the top set for spelling.  What?! I said, astounded.  I say it as his mother but my younger son is a very good speller, all the family know it.  He can certainly spell eligible, better than the teacher who wrote 'elligible' on a note this week, or another school staff member who kept writing 'discrete' for 'discreet'.   He always has been good yet the schools have always given him words to learn that he already knows and they won't be told. I have tried. but it is like banging your head against a wall  But then they aren't teaching the individual.  They too are teaching the class.   No, I only get 26 words a week, he said, and the two people in the top group get 28.  Thus do we have to try to undo the damage of this kind of stupid segregation and labelling - and all for two words that he probably knows anyway.  Did he think it was fair, just, a good assessment by the teacher?  I asked.  Did he himself think the two others could spell better?  Not really, he said.  I told my son I'd never met a child who spells so well and that school doesn't really know a child or much care. But he knows that because if nothing else my kids get hit and no-one tells their mother, or the dinner ladies serve the burgers and chips with their bare hands....(Oh, the things that go on).  Your family knows you though, and cares about you.  Yet it is like the lady who thought she had to work on her feet.  Despite knowing what is true and what counts, the damage is done and keep listening to the ones who harm them.  That kind of hurt sticks because, foolishly, we put our trust in teachers, for whom we are nothing but a job.  They forget about us but the things they have said stick with us in life.  Despite the obvious warning signs we see in the behaviour of school staff and school life, school is responsible for so much of the limitation we put on ourselves in life - in every area.  A lot depends on what you are told by some 'teacher' who should be inspiring and motivating you but so often destroys the budding hope or just enjoyment we have naturally in so many things before we go to school.  Dance is a prime example.  It happened to me in  school in art, sport, maths, science.  I don't have talents in those areas but it might not have taken decades for me to get back the confidence to have even an interest in these things after having it knocked out of me at school from neglect or disregard or put-downs or being relegated to lower categories or just written off into no category at all.  

Know what you can do and what you want to try.  Don't limit yourself because of a label or someone telling you you're some level, like one of my tango teachers who wouldn't let me join a practica until I had done lessons for three or six months.  No one who truly believes in you would try to limit you.  Think of the films where the protagonist outstrips all expectation.  Did it happen because someone was telling her to stick to her level and plod along with everyone else and she'd be a winner?  Or was it just the opposite?  I think a sceptical and questioning outlook, of oneself and of others is healthy - in moderation.  The same is true of self-belief - we need it, in a balance.  But certainly one needs enough of the latter to counter the put-downs, those obvious and more sly from teachers and the co-learners they have succeeded in brainwashing.  People will try to control you and put you in categories because it suits them, for money, for status, for how they feel about themselves, for their targets, their bosses, their bonuses, for all sorts of reasons.  It is just another form of control.  But there is nothing more wonderful than seeing someone breaking free from the constraints of others, finding their own way, being themselves and thus thriving.

Friday, 8 March 2019

How I learnt to dance both roles I:

These days it is not so common to find a case study of how somebody learned to dance in the man's role without or rather in spite of dance classes.  People are often surprised that I learned to dance the man's role like this and they often ask how guys can learn without classes.    

A lot of the process of learning both roles was learning what didn't work.  Essentially, that was in class.  I learned to dance the guy's role by walking and very quickly by dancing to music I knew in the milongas the way you hear guys used to.  It is important to choose understanding women.  I didn't think about steps, about dancing.  It just happened.  Key is to know the music and to already know what dancing as the woman feels like. Much later, I learned specific things by asking guys in practicas to show me by dancing with me and then swapping roles so I could try it out on them. None of this was a plan.  It's just how, through trial and error, things panned out.  It was a much better way than learning through class.

Tuesday, 6 December 2016

Technique: Interference

A: It's a hard thing to embrace a stranger. You have to let go of everything, abandon yourself to the unknown. I imagine it's a totally alien idea to most people, it certainly was for me. Terrifying and thrilling I think is how I remember it, and still sometimes find it that way. And besides that you have to remain yourself, keep that balance of abandonment and still being yourself. How could you teach any of that, right at the start? 

B: You can't. 

A: How can you even bring it up? The fact is, no one would. 

B: Absolutely. A 'professional' telling two regular people how to feel about each other is actually perverted. And so leads to the perverted dance that is class tango.


Friday, 4 November 2016

Keeping schtum

A: One always suspects the bans one actually hears about are likely the tip of an iceberg. It is not far off the numbers I have heard banned from Eton and that some time ago. That is an entirely different thing though being for dangerous floor-craft which I think justifiable because it protects people from injury.

B: From general experience of milongas I think it being the tip of the iceberg is very likely. I believe the majority of people banned don't tell.

A: Perhaps they just assume they are in the wrong. It can be so hard to stand up to supposed authority, or just to someone on their own territory.

B: Those to whom I have talked indicate that they don’t think they are in the wrong, but fear that others will. I think this is because the accuser has teacher 'authority'.

A: But why would someone care what others might think if they believed they were not in the wrong?

B: They might lose dances.

A: If someone was to side with a teacher not ones own banned self, then you wouldn't want to dance with them anyway, so why fear what they think? It doesn't quite stack up.

B:  You wouldn't necessarily know.

A:  Oh, I think you can tell where allegiance lies. You just have to watch.

I suspect those banned might well want to know and, elsewhere, steer clear in dance and in conversation of anyone whose allegiance they weren't sure of.

B:  Unfortunately for many, that would lose most of their dances. 

A:  Well, perhaps some others would rather not know.  I think it comes back again to quantity over quality and also that people dance for different reasons. [Many different perspectives]

I've often found that it can be nicer to dance with someone when you don't know anything about them.

Thursday, 3 November 2016

Banning people

Alpha stock images - Nick Youngson



It was pointed out to me that the page for this milonga says it welcomes all “who enjoy this social/salon style of tango” but it is probably worth noting I have since heard that the number of different people actually and allegedly banned from this milonga for being too sensuous or just generally not toeing those many lines seem to be so numerous I believe some of them joked they might almost form a Facebook group. Then I discovered someone else found the same thing though I don't know whether the people he knows about that are banned are the same that I heard about separately.

I have also discovered since posting about Pant that neither was I alone in feeling nervous there. Not that he’d mind, I guess, being one of those banned (there is a sad interaction which seems to confirm it) but it wasn’t Bob who told me. It seems before that Bob also felt conflicted - receiving, like me a warm welcome and from the dancers as well as the host, yet there is certainly an undercurrent of unease going on in his posts about this group.

There’s more:

A: As one who has yourself experienced Sharons' signature public not-naming but still shaming technique, you'll spot the irony of her accusing Bob of using it. Here's Bob's report of being on the receiving end in her class.

B: Gosh. How interesting and what a useful warning for others. And what a carefully honed and subversive tactic and how difficult to pin down unless one had seen it happen before or to others. How helpful it is when people share. 

And more:

C: [The group] seemed cultesque from what I could gather and not open to alternative or liberal tango views.

In retrospect I can’t shake the feeling that I had some kind of narrow escape.

Banning people, control, rules, milongas with an atmosphere of uncertainty and unease - it's all connected, I think.