Showing posts with label Exploration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Exploration. Show all posts

Wednesday, 29 May 2024

Space





You yourself must strive.

The Buddhas only point the way.

                                             Dhammapada


Talking to someone about getting new dancers started by taking them to milongas he said "You don't actually need to take them, you know.  They can make their own way.  It was a lesson in holding back.  

*


While a teacher talks at a class, a mentor doesn't tell you.  They certainly don't tell you everything at once.  A few great leaders are able to connect with a group of people, to inspire them, to stir emotions that lead them to achieve or to join in some common goal.  But not everyone wants to be part of a group, even a group with a laudable aim.  In contrast, it is hard not to connect with someone who listens.  A mentor probably listens more than they speak.

I wish Instagram had been around when my kids were younger.  There are so many good parenting tips there.  

But something I did consistently, when my kids asked me how to spell something, was say "How do you think?" In fact, just after writing this, my now seventeen year old, whose forte is not spelling, wanted to know how to spell 'umlaut', for a crossword we were doing.  I still used the same approach.

Primary age, they would say, always with their eye on me  A...C...C.... and I would say nothing, so they continued. 

O.....M....A.....  whereupon I would shake my head, once but say nothing.  
U.....Another shake
E....The same again
A....and again

They would start to get frustrated but this passes as they apply thought.  They always got there. There were two lessons and the most important one was not how to spell accommodate.

*

A mentor makes space for a curious mind.  


*
   
It is a light touch that is needed, to help someone find their way, a guiding touch. Though I only saw it in action over one evening, Colin, who was a sensitive guy, had this.

"Life's longing"




 A good mentor holds back. 

Many teachers, and some parents, try to get kids to do it their way but the loveliest thing in any primary school display is the diversity of the art work, the individuality.  Knowing when not to help is probably more important than helping.

A good mentor doesn't help you discover because that would not be the light touch.  It is more someone who shows you where to look but doesn't tell you what to think.  They just point you in the right direction.

Your children are not your children.
They are the sons and daughters of Life’s longing for itself.
They come through you but not from you,
And though they are with you yet they belong not to you.

You may give them your love but not your thoughts,
For they have their own thoughts.
You may house their bodies but not their souls,
For their souls dwell in the house of tomorrow, which you cannot visit, not even in your dreams.
You may strive to be like them, but seek not to make them like you.
For life goes not backward nor tarries with yesterday.
You are the bows from which your children as living arrows are sent forth.
The archer sees the mark upon the path of the infinite, and He bends you with His might that His arrows may go swift and far.
Let your bending in the archer’s hand be for gladness;
For even as He loves the arrow that flies, so He loves also the bow that is stable.

                                                                                        - Khalil Gibran, The Prophet (1923)


It is a captivating image. But maybe a mentor is not even the bow.  The bow implies a goal, chosen in advance and an aim, from experience.  But each person's goal should be their own and aim comes with practice.  The greater the independence, the greater the joy of discovery.  The guide tries to ensure there are no serious injuries. They step in when discouragement threatens abandonment.  They might share a hint when repeated attempts come to naught. 

They observe in the background, anticipating problems, stepping in if danger threatens, or discouragement.

Monday, 5 June 2023

Taking risks






I think this was the day my son slipped off this rope swing, from quite a height and landed in a patch of nettles. He was lucky and I felt guilty, bringing him to this risk, but aside from some bruises he was OK.  In the days and weeks before this, this swing had afforded us all a lot of fun.  When I look at some of the photos of my kids climbing trees and swinging on ropes, I can't regret the joy and look of achievement in their faces but equally I can't help but feel that a) we were lucky, b) these activities, after being normal for millennia, are going the way of riding bikes without helmets; in the UK few people do that now, with good reason. We have become more risk averse, especially with our children. After all, fall out of a tree and your chances of escaping injury or death are not great but how often does it happen?

You are at a milonga where you don't know anyone. Should you take a risk, be less discriminating in who you accept dances from, for fear of scaring all the guys away? I have regretted, many times, lowering my standards.  In the milonga, as in life, a woman who is hard to get is a challenge for a guy and these guys can often dance well. Equally, in the early and even middle years of my tango dance journey I have sat and not danced in many milongas and been miserable.

I accepted a dance with an experienced guy recently at salsa. Gradually it dawned on me that he was drunk but by the time I was sure and was deciding what to do, the dance was over. It was an excruciating experience and thank heavens in salsa people usually seem to dance just one track together.

The next time I saw him, he invited me but I wasn’t sure, particularly whether or not he was sober and I didn't accept - one bitten, twice shy. Later that same evening I saw him playing percussion very well, clearly sober.

At the next event he did not invite me, understandably. Later, I said to him he played well and asked if he was a musician. He said not, just that he had been dancing a long time. I said why I hadn’t danced with him the last time whereupon he invited me and I accepted. 

There is the flexibility of youth, which tries everything and a more careful flexibility that comes with experience and exercising judgement. 

Wednesday, 22 February 2023

Play




Through chat with the a friend in Buenos Aires about steps in tango, came a reminder of a realisation from some years back. My eldest son, still a child or maybe at most a tween, was dancing tango with me in the kitchen. He has never had a lesson or any kind of instruction, he just picked it up, absorbed it, the way I pick up languages, the way his brother somehow picked up reading before school. Maybe it was the years lying on the floor pushing the fridge magnets about in long, mysterious games punctuated only by noises of propulsion. 

The boys came to tea dances and the Edinburgh brunch milonga when they were little so they had seen dancing and they heard the music at home.  The eldest and I didn’t dance together often and when we did it was as much play as dance. He had been good at judo as a younger child. For him the game was as much about seeing if he could leverage me off balance. His dance was full of jokes and fun and experimentation. There was also, from him, an element of challenge. Although he was always tall he was very slight. Dancing with an adult 1.83m tall he had to be quite strong.  

Astonishing was that from his dance play emerged recognised tango moves that I never do:  sacadas, and ganchos I remember distinctly, maybe there were even voleos.  There was a sense of shock, delight and amazement at his discovery, like new land. This has never happened with anyone else. Even Colin, who learned to dance well in a night, without instruction, did not start evolving tango moves spontaneously in quite the same way.  If memory serves, Colin followed what I initiated and then took over the same.  

Watching my son discover the dance came the realisation that this must have been how the moves associated with the dance began originally - through that kind of exploration.  The element of necessary challenge, of pushing boundaries that my son had that probably aided those discoveries, likely also existed between guys dancing together when the dance emerged in Buenos Aires. 

My son was the initiator of the movements, that much was always clear.  He was also the only person with whom I would routinely and completely forget who was in the male role and who the female (in terms of the position of the arms).  Over time, he distinctly took over the arm positions of the male role. 

Sometimes I wonder, whimsically, if there are other moves out there, waiting to be discovered by someone or some couple untainted by class and received ideas of what is "correct". 

So why did these moves emerge with my son? For that kind of game you need a playful spirit, which most adults have lost and no sense of inhibition, which again, most adults have lost. You need that challenging edge.  You probably need a profound intimacy, trust and physical closeness with the dance partner. And for that kind of joint exploration you both need, at the same time, creativity, curiosity, and a sense of adventure.  Put all that together as a recipe list required between two people simultaneously and it's no wonder it doesn't happen often. 

The three of us had always been tactile. We walked hand in hand or arms around one another for years, the boys were constantly in each others arms or the big one carried the little one on his shoulders. My youngest usually sat on my knee rather than a chair for at least the first five years of his life.  Maybe that’s all you need to become a natural and creative tango dancer - a sense of fun and lots of cuddles!





Dancing tango is a shared exploration in movement anyway albeit one of you is often more the guide; this was just more equal somehow, more inventive, more adventurous.  I live in hope I may find it one day in someone again.

Monday, 21 December 2015

Being unique: learning from children





“Anyone who writes down to children is simply wasting his time. You have to write up, not down. Children are demanding. They are the most attentive, curious, eager, observant, sensitive, quick, and generally congenial readers on earth. They accept, almost without question, anything you present them with, as long as it is presented honestly, fearlessly, and clearly. “ E.B. White

This gives children their due.  Children are often told to do this and be that and have all natural joy shaped and moulded into the ways others want them to be yet in a heartbeat they can spring back to an apparently boundless natural optimism and creativity with a speed and resilience not generally matched by adults.

Recently I went to help six or seven year olds with Chrismas crafts at our school.  On the table allocated to me the teacher had prepared an example of a Christmas card with a Christmas tree design and the material to make it.  Here is a similar version.  




To make the cards, there was a triangular template made from card, Christmas wrapping paper, pre-cut into strips, glue and scissors.  At the table there were spaces for six children at a time.  When they had finished they rotated on to tables with other activities. Few children asked what they had to do.  Most, must have, I suppose, glanced at the card but plunged straight in.  A few hesitated for a moment, looking to me for guidance. “Guidance” it turned out just meant in most cases, showing them where to start by pointing out the pile of coloured card so that they could choose from the selection, and sometimes passing them the tree template.  

The lovely thing was that nobody just copied the example card.  Some made their strips all one way.  Some used the card to cut out other pieces of card to make tree decorations.  Somebody decided to make a border to their card using these strips, someone else decided to use a spare cut-out star to decorate their tree’s pot, someone asked how to curl the paper like ribbon to make curly decorations for their tree like this..



All the children's cards were very creative and completely individual.  Sometimes, one of the ideas would live for a bit among the other children.  For a while a few people did borders, then there was a ribbon curling phase.  I loved how the ideas appeared and were shared, lived for a while and gave way to others.

Everyone completed a card with little assistance, more a sense of support, of being, as Tango Commuter put it recently “pointed in the right direction”.  One boy folded his card the “wrong” way and like one or two other boys seemed generally hesitant and so uncertain I thought he was going to struggle with many things.  In fact no.  We just made his card into a unique, tall card, he took his time and was happy with the result.  In this expressive activity there were no “mistakes”.  

How these children learned seemed to me so different to the overthinking that happens when adults are taught improvised social dancing in class. Simple Scottish country dancing of the kind danced in ceilidhs is different because it is a series of sequences though I and most have learnt them socially. But Argentine tango and also swing - from the little of it I have danced - is improvised and best learnt socially by dancing with experienced people as it used to be. In fact, I danced swing (of a sort) with my elder son yesterday in the kitchen and was delighted when he, who dances tango, immediately initiated entirely different swing sorts of movements that he had not seen from me.  

In the craft classroom the children obviously were not paying anyone or expecting anything in return.  The children were as focused as you see adults in dance class, but only because it is a natural state for them, not one caused by intent on an ROI. The children were relaxed and natural and happy,  brimming with creativity and experimentation, like my son when he dances who has never been to tango or swing dance class; like most children  in fact and some untrained adults when they feel moved to dance.


Local cafe

It was the same later in the week at the school Christmas concert which for me is when Christmas really feels like it begins.  Each class sang two Christmas songs.  There were traditional songs and party songs.  It was the variety that I enjoyed.  The ones that were nicest to watch were those where you could see those same qualities I felt in the craft class - the ones where the children were most happy, having fun and relaxed.  These tended to be the younger classes.  Even within the cohesion required for group song you could see the individuality expressed in the children’s faces, their Christmas clothes, the instrumental moments in the songs when they all danced - in all the ways in fact in which they expressed themselves.

In craft class, a cd was playing.  The children spontaneously burst into favourite Christmas songs.   How they were in themselves directly affected what they made.  They did copy an example, but it was only an example - a basis for their own ideas.  There was no forcing it on them, no exactitude, no repetition, no oppression, no right, no wrong.  The cards were all individual, very loose interpretations of the example and all the better for it.


Tuesday, 15 September 2015

The Scotch Hop

Linlithgow palace


Dancing tango is not I think, best learned in class.  Neither is Scottish country dancing, or at least the simpler forms of it that you usually find at ceilidhs - the simpler, party version of scottish country dancing.  Tango and ceilidh dancing are very different - one is wholly improvised, the other strictly a dance of patterns or set sequences.  You might think the way you learn both would be completely different, but I don't think so.

I took my sons to the first and last dances of the wonderful "Scotch hop" which takes place usually in the courtyard of Linlithgow Palace five times in July and August.   Video.  Would that there were more of these in other Historic Scotland or National Trust for Scotland properties.  There we met up with friends, and saw some of the local tango dancers out to ceilidh for the night.




My children and I have been going to the Scotch Hop for about four years, since my younger son was a toddler.  It is one of the highlights of our summer.  In the past they have gone happily, less for the dancing I think and more for the atmosphere of music, dance and excitement.  There is the promise of a ruined palace with dizzingly tall towers to explore up dark spiral staircases with juice and shortbread at half time.  Afternoon picnics, ice cream and adventure playground are the inevitable afternoon precursors to those long, light evenings.  In the picture below my younger son begins a happy association between sweet things and dance at the Scotch Hop.


Half time at the Scotch Hop, 2012

That association has continued on occasional trips to the much-loved Dalmeny Tango Tea Dances just north of Edinburgh with warm hosts Willie and Louise where the food is magnificent and sometimes there are even little girls to run around with outside, who may even dance (in the middle of the ronda).

Dalmeny, January 2015

It has often struck me as I ferry my children to activities in the modern manner how segregated by age these activities are. It is true of everything from tennis to art. I would rather they played football, informally, as yesterday, with a crowd of boys aged six to adult, speaking an unknown language  in the park in front of our house than they attend planned, structured and segregated activities which teaches them if anything that the kind of easy social interaction they had on the field is unusual.  

In Kaduna, Nigeria  during the late seventies my parents had an active social life at parties held in the houses of other, mostly military personnel who were there at the invitation of the Nigerian government.  Very occasionally we went as a family not to the smart Polo club but to the more imaginatively named Crocodile Club.  The crocodile is the symbol of the city.  It was a social club attended by ex-pats from all over the world most of whom were probably there because of the country's sudden oil wealth.  The adults went to drink and chat.  My father said there was a light lunch ("small chop").  I don't remember a garden as such.  More a kind of compound with plants suitably large for hide and seek, and below our feet the dusty, packed red earth.  For us children there was a sudden thrill in being outside in a new place, with other children we didn't usually see, the sense of adventure and freedom and yet with the knowledge, reachable, that our parents were around somewhere.  

Mine was perhaps the last generation of at least British children to have the freedom to roam and explore.  There were snakes and scorpions and terrifyingly large orange and black spiders with yellow webs, storm ditches with god knows what inside, mounds of rubbish with goats atop, afternoon downpours and low lightning, narrow paths through fields of tall sugar cane, mango trees that were great to climb but caused a rash, each bump, housing, we told each other with quiet horror, a little wriggling worm.  We explored it all on bikes and in small gangs and alone. 

The Scotch Hop is also wonderfully multi-generational in the way of the way of the Crocodile Club though given the palace's tall towers, open windows and the age in which we live when parents - me, I'm afraid included - are inexplicably so much less relaxed than our parents were, the children tend to have significantly less freedom to explore alone.

With granny, (left) 2012

This year was the first that my eight year old, Orry, wanted to dance all the dances with his friend Milly.  Neither of them really knew any of the dances; perhaps they had a dim recollection of the Gay Gordons from school or previous ceilidhs. The dances are "called": you walk through the simple routine once or twice before the music starts, but at age eight, I'm not sure how much that helps.  Before the dances the uncertainty, fear and resolve were written all over his face.  But provided they were in a set (group) with experienced people to help, or he could identify an experienced couple to copy, they were fine and went back time and again.  Ceilidhs are just about taking part and trying things out.  Even six year old Henry and little Charlotte wanted to try out two couple dances on their own.

She loved her first experience at the beginning of the summer - so much so that she wanted to make the last hop the focus of her fifth birthday which was on the same day.  Her mother and I, near them in a long line of dancers with partners our own height wondered how they were going to manage Orcadian Strip the Willow where you alternate between birling your partner and endless numbers of other men, women, boys and girls at speed for an exhilarating, dizzying, exhaustingly long time.  But seeing the two of them clap and stamp to the rhythm and jump up and down with sheer excitement and pleasure was one of my great memories of this summer.   Willing hands (and the superb volunteers) helped them down the line of dozens of couples. There is something wonderful about children participating, learning from others within the group especially when the learning is the by-product of the overall experience which is of music, dance, anticipation and laughter.

Thanks to Alix and Michal for permission to publish these photos and to Sue Anderson of The Scotch Hop for permission to use the photo of Linlithgow Palace.